UNDER CONSTRUCTION
FACTSHPI PHYSICAL EXAMIMAGINGTrials Symptomatic TrialsNASCET (1991)ECSTCREST (2010) Symptomatic trialsACAS ACST CAVATAS (2002) CREST 2 (ongoing)
FACTS
- approximately 15-30% of ischemic strokes 2/2 cervical carotid stenosis
- pathophysiology of ischemic strokes:
- arterial to arterial emboli
- in situ thrombosis (entire vessel shuts down)
- low flow-watershed infarction
IMAGING
MRI Brain without:
evaluate for strokes.
MRI neck:
- evaluate for e/o lipid necrosis
carotid ultrasound
- evaluate for e/o lipid necrosis
- very good for evaluating circumferentially Ca2+ carotid stenosis
CTA head and neck:
- best study
- evaluate for associated Ca2+
- evaluate relative height of bifurcation
- evaluate for e/o tandem stenosis intracranially (iCAD)
Definition of stenosis (below)
String sign: entire carotid is small. Unique situation where you should probably not be operating.
A/P
Consider high-risk criteria for each modality
ㅤ | Carotid endarterectomy (CEA) | Carotid artery stenting (CAS) |
ㅤ | Anatomic high risk - Tandem stenosis > 70% - bilateral carotid stenosis - contralateral carotid occlusion - recurrent carotid stenosis - high (> C2) or low (< clavicle) bifurcation Physiologic high risk - ≥ 75 years - NYHA CHV 3-4 - CAD ≥ 2 vessels - unstable angina - recent MI (within 6 weeks) - severe pulmonary disease - chronic renal insufficiency | ㅤ |
Absolute c/i | - prior neck radiation (high risk venous/nerve injury) | ㅤ |
TCAR: a way to bypass proximal risk and do an
- tortuosity in chest and proximal calcifications in plaque is a big problem, especially in the elderly chronically calcified vessels
- TCAR is CAS but allows you to directly access carotid artery
Decision tree
ㅤ | Severe Stenosis (≥ 70%) | S |
Symptomatic | ㅤ | ㅤ |
Asymptomatic | ㅤ | ㅤ |
Other notes
Timing matters: “hot carotid,” re-vascularize within 24-48h to capture most of the benefit (dwindles over time, less yield from surgery)
Trials
Symptomatic Trials
NASCET (1991)
- Population: 649 symptomatic patients with carotid stenosis ≥ 70%
- Definition of stenosis: A (stable segment of ICA distal to vessel) minus B (narrowest region in the stenosis)
- best medical management: 1300 mg ASA qDaily
- Conclusion:
- Stroke rate in best medical treatment (26-28% in 2-5 years) vs. stroke rate in medical treatment + CEA (9-13% 2-5 years) p < 0.001.
- Absolute risk reduction: 17% at 2 years, 15% at 5 years
ECST
CREST (2010)
- Symptomatic 2502 patients (2000-2008)
- Designed as a non-inferiority study(allows for a relatively underpowered studies)
- Arms:
- CEA (carotid endarterectomy)
- CAS (Carotid artery stenting)
- required pre-specified complication rate for eligibility (< 3% if symptomatic, < 5% if asymptomatic)
- Conclusions
- stenting non-inferior
Paramater and significance | CEA | CAS |
peri-operative stroke risk (p = 0.01) | 2.3% | 4.1% |
MI (p = 0.03) | 2.3% | 1.1% |
Restenosis rates similar (HR 1.24) | ㅤ | ㅤ |
Symptomatic trials
ACAS
- first major randomized trial of ASYMPTOMATIC disease
- Population: 1662 asymptomatic patients with ≥ 60% stenosis
- Conclusion:
- Stroke rate in best medical treatment (11% at 5 years) vs. stroke rate in medical treatment + CEA (5.1% at 5 years) p = 0.004.
- Absolute risk reduction: 5.9% at 5 years
ACST
CAVATAS (2002)
CREST 2 (ongoing)
ongoing trial evaluating asymptomatic stenosis in a 3 arm trial
- CEA
- carotid angioplasty + stenting
- medical management